The employer spent more.
The employee did not feel better paid.
No one necessarily made a bad decision.
Healthcare simply became more expensive.
The renewal increased.
The employer absorbed part of it.
The employee may have absorbed another part through higher premiums, a larger deductible, or a smaller raise.
More money went toward compensation.
Less of it reached the paycheck.
This is one of the strange things about employer sponsored healthcare.
The employer experiences it as a major investment in employees.
The employee experiences it as something deducted from a paycheck and a card they hope will work when care is needed.
Both experiences are real.
They are also moving further apart.
An employer may spend significantly more to preserve the same health plan.
The employee may see the same network, the same deductible, and the same difficulty finding an appointment.
From one side, the benefit became more expensive.
From the other, it did not become more valuable.
This is not because employees are ungrateful.
Most people do not experience benefits through an annual statement showing their total compensation.
They experience them when someone in the household needs help.
Can I get an appointment?
How much will this cost?
Can I leave work?
Does this need urgent care?
Will someone answer tonight?
That is where the value of the benefit becomes visible.
Or does not.
For years, employers have been placed in a difficult position.
Absorb the increase.
Pass part of it to employees.
Reduce something else.
Change plans.
Narrow the network.
Increase the deductible.
None of the choices feels particularly good.
The employer may be trying to protect wages and maintain coverage at the same time.
The employee may simply feel that both healthcare and the rest of life have become more expensive.
The result is a compensation problem disguised as a benefits problem.
Every additional dollar spent on healthcare has to come from somewhere.
Sometimes it comes from profit.
Sometimes it comes from hiring.
Sometimes it comes from the amount available for raises.
Sometimes it returns to the employee as another payroll deduction.
The healthcare system receives more.
The employer and employee may both feel like they have less.
We have been thinking about what a benefit should do in that environment.
It cannot simply exist.
It has to work harder.
It should make the first step clearer.
It should remove uncertainty from common healthcare decisions.
It should give people a way to ask questions before the available options become more disruptive or expensive.
It should recognize that the employee’s household is part of the employee’s healthcare experience.
It should fit into the workday instead of always requiring the workday to move around it.
None of this replaces insurance.
Insurance remains essential for specialists, hospital care, surgery, major diagnoses, and the many other services people may need.
But insurance coverage and practical access are not the same thing.
A person can have excellent coverage and still wait several days for an appointment.
They can have a broad network and still be unsure who to call.
They can have preventive care covered and still postpone it because the visit requires half a day away from work.
The card may say the care is available.
The person’s life may say otherwise.
This is why the front of the healthcare experience matters.
Someone needs a dependable place to begin.
Sometimes the answer can be provided through a text or phone conversation.
Sometimes a video visit is appropriate.
Sometimes a clinician needs to examine the person at home or work.
Sometimes the right next step is a specialist, imaging, medication, or the emergency room.
The value is not in keeping every person inside one service.
It is in helping them reach the right next step sooner and with less confusion.
Employers may not be able to stop healthcare costs from rising.
They can decide whether part of their healthcare investment creates access employees can feel.
That may mean fewer passwords.
Fewer unanswered questions.
Less uncertainty about cost.
Less time trying to determine where to go.
A clearer beginning for the employee and the household.
When the healthcare budget grows faster than the paycheck, every benefit has to prove its value.
Not during open enrollment.
Not on the total compensation statement.
On the ordinary day when someone needs care.
The employer spent more.
The employee should be able to feel where some of that value went.